Breastfeeding Battles

DSC00912Online society in particular has this thing where you have to be pro or con on the breastfeeding stance (this is how it comes across, I am not at all saying breast feeding mothers are exclusively bottle feeding haters and anti formula Nazis)

I have felt more shame feeding my son a bottle of formula than I ever did while breastfeeding him and honestly, I breast fed anywhere, walking around the shops, while waiting in ques. At 5 weeks old we had a photo shoot at a pop up “Tickled Pink” stand and he got upset so I fed him, discretely, then and there.

I had people stop to chat to me while feeding him, who patted his head and commented on how cute he was and they didn’t even know I was feeding him at the time, and told me so when they realized (as I redid my bra). There was never a moment of shaming me for feeding in public, just warm smiles and pats on the back. It was a very positive experience for me.

20131130_182642(0) (1)So when we switched to bottle feeding due to lactose intolerance, the shaming started. Mostly family members (who are bolder than strangers I find) asking me “Oh, your bottle feeding him then are you? I thought you were breast feeding. so and so breast fed for X amount of time, that was a good amount I think.” It’s like they think not actually saying to your face you have failed as a mother, in the most basic way possible, feeding your baby, but conveying that exact message through passive aggressive “polite” sentences and that “I know better than you” tone isn’t as offensive and degrading as just saying it outright.

And others commenting on future plans “oh, we are going to breast feed exclusively” when seeing you pull out a bottle.

Well good for you, so were we. Our baby spent months vomiting most of what he drank and was gaining only just enough weight for the MCHN to be unconcerned (especially as he was not showing pain). From four months we started introducing formula as Bubs was refusing the breast except for night time feeds. After much trial and error we discovered our little man is Lactose intolerant and by 6 months old he was exclusively formula fed Lactose free formula.

This was not our plan! I’m glad I don’t have anything against bottle feeding or I would have been devastated. There is so much Anti Bottle negativity splashed all over the internet.

While looking through the Australian Breastfeeding Association website I couldn’t find any positive messages around bottle feeding. In fact I couldn’t all that was mentioned in their Statements was that they don’t recommend alternatives to breastfeeding unless medically advised. And even stating “ It is the right of every mother to have access to up-to-date evidence based information about breastfeeding so that she can make informed choices. It is also the right of every mother to be made aware of the health risks associated with not breastfeeding, and the health impact to herself and her baby.”

Yes, there is research all over the place informing us that Breast is Best and that for optimal health in our babies and in fact throughout their who lives we MUST EXCLUSIVELY BREASTFEED our children for as long as possible but definitely through the first year.

DSC04355For so many Mothers this is not actually possible. Or not wanted, which is perfectly OK too. The message that needs to be sent is that feeding our babies, no matter how (as long as it is actually designed for babies and meets the Australian Safety Standards-so not cordial) is what we should be striving for.

Education is key. We need to promote the pros and cons of each with accurate information on both sides. Breastfeeding is not a dirty act, and formula is not a dirty word. both are feeding our children.
So, here is a little information about both.

According to ABA breast fed babies are more resistant to disease and infection in early life than formula fed babies.
However this has been recently disputed by Professor Sven Carlsen who claims after more than 50 studies into the relationship between breastfeeding vs formula and the effect on health he cannot conclusively find evidence suggesting that today’s formula is any less beneficial than breast milk for our babies. That outside factors had far greater effect on infant health than whether the baby was fed breast milk or formula.

  • Breastfeeding offers mothers a variety of health benefits including lowering the risk of breast cancer, Uterine cancer and ovarian cancer and lessens the likelihood of developing Osteoporosis later in life.
  • Breastfeeding helps the Uterus contract back to its former size after birth.
  • Breastfeeding aids in post pregnancy weight loss (which I can attest to) However as I personally found I had to eat constantly to keep up my supply, especially as Bubs feeds dropped off and I was trying to express to maintain supply, once I stopped feeding regularly I stacked the weight back on very quickly. So it is no replacement for a balanced diet and regular exercise, it’s a great help but not a magical cure all.
  • Formula is expensive. Trying to find the right formula for you and your baby can be a very pricey journey. Some of the most expensive formula’s made my baby vomit as well as the cheaper ones. I am Glad we found a mid range Lactose free formula that works for us.
  • Convenience. There is argument for this on both sides. It is SO MUCH EASIER to breastfeed on the run. You don’t have to worry about bottles and formula tins and sterilizing and temperatures and teat flow and different nipples. It’s all on hand (or in shirt) ready to go at all times (provided all is working as it should), but then, it is so handy to have Hubby get up at 3am and feed bubs while you sleep. To feed bubs in the car or pram and not have to get them out to fuss around if your in a hurry. To not feel pressured to find a feeding room (if you are so inclined) if returning to work, formula is so much more convenient that expressing every four hours to keep up your supply and ensuring you have enough milk in reserve for bubs while in care.
  • Emotional state and bonding (keep in mind this is my personal opinion through my own experiences) I Hate the argument that Breast fed babies have a stronger bond with their mother. The baby is still carried by their mother, loved by their mother, comforted by their mother and yes, even fed by their mother. Breast feeding is lovely, but Bottle feeding is actually more inclusive of the fathers and other family and friends if that’s what the mother wants. I have had fathers tell me they wished that they could be more involved in the feeding process of their little ones, that they wish for the closeness that comes from providing the life nourishing milk that is essential for babies to survive, no matter of how they receive it. From starting out breast feeding (and pushing through pain to do so) I felt close to my baby, but no less so than giving his a bottle. It was wonderful in the early days when our house was full to be able to go and sit in the privacy of my bedroom and feed him to get away from the commotion of a full house wanting to be with the new arrival, but honestly, I probably would have done that anyway (would have offended people in doing so, but I don’t really care that much) my 11 month old still cuddles in the same now as he did on the boob, the only difference is it’s a bottle he is drinking from and not the breast he is snuggled into.
  • DSC06054Breast feeding provides comfort for an upset baby. Yes, it does. However my bottle fed son is no less comforted by a cuddle from Mummy than he would be from a feed. That makes things easier for me. I don’t have to feed him because Daddy said “boo” too loudly or because he fell over and bumped his head. A nice cuddle and he is all better and off again to explore his ever expanding world. And when Mummy is not around, he gains comfort from cuddles with whoever he is with. A cuddle is his band-aid, not a feed. Which for me is a big bonus. (and a mummy cuddle is nest, but Daddy or his friends Mummy will do in a pinch)
  • Breast feeding is natures contraceptive. But there are SO MANY OPTIONS out there anyway ranging from minor and temporary to perminant. For the most part we are adults who at least by now know all about the birds and the bee’s and how we got pregnant in the first place and how not to have an untimely pregnancy.

I have actually so far only found one site where breastfeeding and Formula feeding were talked about evenly and equally and that was on WebMD. I really like the way the facts are stated and it is totally unbiased. So for more information I recommend having a read. Especially if you are struggling with your decision on which way to go. The Australian Breast feeding Association is also a great resource, just keep in mind they are 100% breast feeding advocates so you wont find support for bottle feeding there.

Guest Contributor

We love guest posts at Parenting Central so we can deliver you a variety of voices and perspectives. We take submissions from other writers, or people who just have a story to tell. If you'd like to submit an article please contact


  1. What a load of ……. I’m sorry but I do feel that bottle feeding is encouraged far more than Breastfeeding. I’m continuously being told to give my child formula so he’ll sleep the night. If you join the breastfeeding associations and become a member, you’ll find that women on there do support both bottle and boob on the forum.

    1. i am glad that there is discussion and support for both methods of feeding in the forums, however, have a read of the official statements and try to find anything positive about bottle feeding. ABA is a great resourse for mothers breastfeeding and for issues surrounding breastfeeding, maintaining supply and anything related to breastfeeding and breast milk. Please keep in mind the article is aimed at Feeding stigma’s and that any way of feeding should be welcomed openly. the article is also about MY experiences of which breast feeding was positive and i recieved no negativity what so ever (socially anyway) and my bottle feeding has had plenty of judgement. each persons experience is valid and not “a load of …..” we all have our difficulties andjudgements made. as long as we are doing our best (in our own estimations) it really should not be such a big social issue. thanks for reading.

    2. Obviously you’ve ever experienced someone telling you it was offensive feeding in public, you ought to cover up then or told your child should be off breastmilk as there’s no benefit after 6 months, or told it’s creepy when a 2 year old can ask for milk and you’re still breastfeeding a child that can speak….I understand that was HER experience, but obviously hasn’t experienced some of the negatives others have breastfeeding.

  2. Couldn’t agree more Melissa! Breast or bottle – it is 100% a personal choice which should be based on what works for mum & bub in their individual circumstances.
    A representative of the ABA was recently interviewed saying that you are still better off breastfeeding your baby after a night of heavily drinking alcohol than giving your baby formula. Essentially she was saying that formula is more harmful to a baby than alcohol!!!
    I was disgusted on behalf of every parent out there that for whatever reason isn’t able to breastfeed.

  3. Dr Carlsen’s claims have been described as over inflated and his apparent findings have not changed the guidelines from leading health authorities anywhere- and his review was 4 years ago. While I’m totally ok with formula or breast, having done both, formula does not have the enzymes and antibodies breast milk has. While it’s true that some claims around BM are exaggerated, it can’t be denied that the vast majority of babies digest it more easily and gain immunological benefits.
    I’m sorry you were treated poorly for bottle feeding- I’ve copped it for both- can’t win! But I’m not surprised you didn’t find bottle feeding support at the ABA- that’s not why they are there. Have you checked out the Fearless Formula Feeder blog and fb? You might find it a good resource/ support 🙂

  4. Everyone is different, I personally felt very uncomfortable breast feeding in public, not because of any negativity I felt from others but because I’m a private person, I also feel very uncomfortable in a bathing suit on a public beach – that’s my issue, nobody else’s. I found my baby was very hungry, he would feed continuously to the point of my exhaustion, I fed in combination with formula and he eventually self-weaned at around 9 months, he would snuggle but would just chew me and use me as a dummy so I stopped breast feeding in the end. When baby first arrived the nursing staff never gave me the option of formula feeding, they never asked what I wanted, they assumed I was breast feeding and promptly manhandled me and baby till we got it right…

Related Articles